Can we improve peer review? We think we can! Check out an experiment I helped with as part of @solvingforsci.bsky.social 's mission to make science better.
And if you don't want to read the whole bioRxiv manuscript, here's an overview of the main findings:
solvingfor.org/news-posts-d...
solvingfor.org
Reimagining Peer Review: Feasibility and Value of a Scientist-Designed, Metric-Driven Model
Always great to see peer review experiments with actual data. SolvingForScience distinguish Quality (Q) & Impact (I) scores for papers. Q scores are based on a peer-improvement phase, followed by an I assessment by a different group. Unsurprisingly I varies more than Q 1/2
doi.org/10.1101/2025...
