4/ AI reviewers think alike
Across >75K ICLR 2026 reviews, fully AI-generated reviews are significantly more similar to each other than human ones – both within papers and across papers
6/ Huge thanks to the helpful feedback of 4 anonymous reviewers. Small N, but all opted into ICML 2026's LLM Policy A – strictly no LLMs in reviewing.
Engaging with real human reviews feels good 🫶